Special Feature:

Venezuelans on Venezuela

Dissonant Solidarity

Venezuela and the International Left

Img 01-e9111e.jpg

This clarification might be unnecessary, but since this article has a very specific target audience, I want to make sure that after reading the title, your ideological programming doesn’t short-circuit and cause you to stop before reaching what is truly important:

I do not subscribe to the ideas, the methods, or the discourse of Donald Trump - nor to neoliberalism, nor to imperialism (of any kind). Much less do I celebrate the death of compatriots of any kind, nor the fact that, at least for the foreseeable future, we Venezuelans have been incapable of providing a solution to our own problems - neither through peaceful means nor by force - to guarantee some degree of control over our own destiny.

My family, Venezuelan and Basque, is a melting pot of anti-Francoist/anti-fascist exiles - persecuted Republicans who had to flee after the fall of the Second Spanish Republic (never to return) - and working-class Venezuelans who made the transition from the countryside to the city in a true display of social mobility as our democracy, now absolutely destroyed, consolidated itself during the 20th century.

Furthermore, I am a product of Venezuela’s free, public university education system and a staunch defender of its autonomy.

All of this makes me fundamentally opposed to totalitarianism, impositions, and, of course, social injustice. It also makes me understand the need for international law and order that guarantees we do not return to an era where strong states can trample the weak without consequence.

Even if none of the above were true, the suffering of an individual or a collective - especially the level of suffering we Venezuelans have endured (forced migration, humiliation, political persecution, fear, torture, extrajudicial executions, legal and illegal abuses, impoverishment, and much more) - does not cease to be real simply because the person suffering does not share your worldview.

Img 02.jpg

If you have made it this far and are capable of empathizing with what I’ve explained, keep reading. If not, you are just one more “lost cause” - one of those who put pseudo-ideological loyalties before critical thinking; perhaps something closer to a religious fanatic than a human capable of experiencing pain through the eyes of another or showing some empathy. Some “solidarity” that is!

If you have the perception that the vast majority of Venezuelans you encounter lean to the right and influence your country’s politics by voting for and backing candidates you dislike, the reason is quite simple:

EVERY ABUSE COMMITTED IN VENEZUELA OVER THE LAST 25 YEARS WAS DONE IN THE NAME OF SOCIALISM.

Img 03.jpg

Yes, we can debate at length which of Chávez’s - and later Maduro’s - policies were truly leftist; whether the system’s collapse was due to corruption or a structural flaw in its conception; whether the dream was diverted; whether Marx, Gramsci, Bernstein, or Rosa Luxemburg; reform or revolution; Bolívar, Sandino, Che, or Martí; pragmatic communism; or whether “it doesn’t matter the color of the cat as long as it catches mice.”

It doesn’t matter. None of these intellectual justifications matter (nor will they ever matter) to the mother of a student murdered in a protest; to the person who had to cross the Andes on foot; to the person who swallowed a ton of tear gas claiming their rights; or to the person who lost everything the moment they left their homeland.

In English, it is often said that even a broken clock is right twice a day. That Maduro is in a cell is good for Venezuelans, regardless of how it happened and regardless of the major reservations that remain about whether there will be a true transition to democracy.

Img 04.jpg

How This Finally Happened

For years, the regional left, the European left, and a good part of the global left - what Teodoro Petkoff called the “Borbonic Left” because of its inability to mutate, adapt to the times, or recognize past mistakes - not only ignored the thousands of complaints we made from Venezuela but openly cheered the “Bolivarian Revolution” while it advanced its designs based on a petro-checkbook that would later deflate.

These complaints came from across the entire political spectrum: from Marxist-Leninist organizations like the Communist Party of Venezuela or Bandera Roja; social democrats like Acción Democrática or Un Nuevo Tiempo; centrist or Christian-democratic parties like Primero Justicia or Voluntad Popular; and others further into liberalism like Vente Venezuela, María Corina Machado’s party. A polyphony of voices pointing to the same thing: human rights were being violated in Venezuela and the population was being trampled.

It wasn’t just political parties. Labor unions, social movements, professional guilds, NGOs (those that have a lot of legitimacy when they talk about Gaza but none when they talk about Caracas), university movements, and intellectuals - everyone denounced, over and over again, how the democratic space was closing and we were falling at an accelerated pace into a kleptocratic nightmare with totalitarian overtones.

Many leftist personalities, some who have even become global icons, held power during this time: Lula, Gustavo Petro, Michelle Bachelet, Gabriel Boric, Pepe Mujica, Pedro Sánchez, just to name a few. Their positions, when they had the chance to seriously confront what was happening in Venezuela, moved between lukewarm denunciation and direct logistical, economic, and political support for the regime.

It is true that some, behind the scenes and timidly, made diplomatic efforts to find a solution when the crisis began to cross borders and the continent filled with refugees. But it was clearly insufficient. In most cases, their principles - or their selfish interests - did not allow them to recognize the level of disaster they had legitimized.

Img 05.jpg

Hiding behind the errors, blunders, and - in many cases - severely questionable behavior of the opposition leadership, they washed their hands of their neighbors’ suffering and dropped the flag of justice. Despite their own countries having gone through equally terrible dictatorships or conflicts, they did not confront the victimizers - which is equivalent to ignoring the victims, no matter what justification they want to give now.

Gravity does not forgive; a vacuum calls to whoever wants to fill it. In the Venezuelan case, it has been filled by Donald Trump and his allies - whose values are absolutely foreign to me and many Venezuelans - whose focus is shamelessly on profiting from a collapsed country, but whose interests (at least instantaneously on January 3rd) aligned with the aspirations of millions who felt abandoned and betrayed by those who should have been the first at their side.

Img 06.jpg

It’s okay. You are still in time to collaborate and help Venezuelans without giving up your convictions. By doing so, you won’t be helping Donald Trump - or maybe you will, I don’t know - but fundamentally you will be contributing to improving our lives and those of our families.

How can you do it? First, by understanding several things:

Maduro is not a revolutionary kidnapped by the empire. He is also likely not the head of a cartel (at least in the strict sense of the word). He is simply a dictator and a criminal responsible for the collapse of a country; the death of hundreds of protesters; and thousands of extrajudicial executions - who openly ignored the popular will after the July 28, 2024 elections. Along with military and civilians (like the Rodríguez siblings) who remain in charge of the country, he is also responsible for the embezzlement of billions of dollars of Venezuelan resources.

The “Bolivarian Revolution” never stopped selling oil to the United States. Yes, they diversified their client portfolio and allied with Russia and China as an alternative. But for a good part of the last 25 years - even in the most heated moments of bilateral relations - business with the “gringos” never ended. Chevron - yes, the same Chevron with a criminal record - was, for the last few years, one of the regime’s main economic supporters, with special permits to operate despite sanctions.

Although this doesn’t directly justify a foreign military intervention, Venezuelan sovereignty has been compromised for years. The levels of debt acquired by Venezuela with Russians and Chinese in exchange for geopolitical support, or the lifeline thrown from Caracas to Havana to keep another dictatorial regime standing with our money, are just a few concrete examples that the government’s anti-imperialist discourse does not hold up. The documented presence of Colombian irregular groups controlling territory and illegal business flows is another. So is the confirmation by the Cuban government that most of the military who died protecting Maduro came from that country.

Maduro offered a “blank check” to Donald Trump. Before his capture, he offered Trump and American companies the chance to massively exploit Venezuelan oil in exchange for legitimizing him in power and forgetting the 2024 presidential elections. It was a pragmatic deal that Trump and Marco Rubio were not willing to make with him - but they were with his successors, at least for the moment.

The January 3rd operation bears the marks of betrayal. It is known that the CIA had assets infiltrated inside the government who provided information on Maduro’s location and habits. It is also still debated whether the absolute collapse of anti-aircraft defenses was due only to the military superiority of the units involved - or if there was internal help in deactivating them. One day it will be known.

While you scream about “intervention,” the supposed victims have already turned the page and are “open for business,” capitulating and striking deals with the Americans to protect their lives, their impunity, or their indefinite hold on power. This deal had already been offered since the last quarter of 2024 in Qatar.

The economic collapse started long before the sanctions. It began when oil prices collapsed after being inflated by George W. Bush’s blunders in Iraq and Afghanistan. Shortly before dying, Chávez himself announced the need for an absolute shift in the economic model that never materialized. One could argue the military man himself saw the inviability of his project - and died before facing the consequences.

You don’t have to like María Corina Machado to recognize her leadership. Many, like me, see how she has been displaced by the very forces she set in motion. In a country where democracy returns, we would have the possibility to settle that conflict peacefully and electorally.

The poor and the working class in Venezuela ARE NOT WITH MADURO. That myth ended years ago; it possibly was never entirely real. In 2015, the opposition coalition swept the elections. From that moment on, the regime decided not to truly compete for ten years. And when it did so again in 2024, it was razed at the polls. Today, the repudiation of Chavismo is not a matter of class - it is a cross-cutting sentiment in our country.

Government propaganda financed a global campaign. Aided largely by the Russian communication apparatus (see the alliance between Telesur and RT), they reached out to “alternative” causes worldwide - from Palestine to the Sahara; from sectors of the Basque Left to pan-Arabist regimes; from Iranian theocracy to the anti-globalist U.S. protesters of the early 2000s and Black Lives Matter. They wove a network that allowed Chavismo to present itself as a patron of progressive causes while using the military boot to repress and murder in its own territory.

Venezuelan society is as broad as yours and deserves the chance to reconfigure itself freely. The privileges and benefits you enjoy were forcibly canceled for us for two and a half decades, and when you defend the ones who did it, you re-victimize an entire population.

Don’t take my word for it. As soon as you finish reading this, do your own research. Look at the numbers and statistics again with new eyes. Talk to those of us who have suffered this firsthand. Get out of the echo chamber you have carefully curated on social media and take a walk through the real world.

Then, mobilize with us so that, instead of throwing a tantrum and complaining fruitlessly about the actions of the U.S. government, you can pressure your own country, your party comrades, or your peers to stand up against those who seek to commit similar abuses in other parts of the world.

Help us push a collective cry to ensure that everything that has happened opens the way for a true democratic transition in Venezuela - finishing the dismantling of the remnants of the dictatorship that now servilely seek to get on good terms with the “new master,” so as not to be definitively replaced.

If after all this you still don’t understand, then, respectfully and using your own terminology: do not seek to help anymore - and at least do not go protest in front of a gringo embassy after you failed to do so in front of one of ours.

HANDS OFF F*CKING VENEZUELA.

In Conversation:
Topics:
Filed under:

Admin:

Download docx

Schedule Newsletter

More from: Luken Ignacio Quintana